The Justice Project
The Docket
North Carolina Supreme Court
Home / Decisions / Upchurch v. Harp Builders, Inc., et al.
Upchurch v. Harp Builders, Inc., et al.
Filed March 22, 2024

The vote

6–0
Unanimous
6 of 7 justices participating
Did not participate 1 justice Took no part in deciding the case

Lineup parsed from the opinion and verified against the PDF.

Issue

Compulsory counterclaim—relation back to filing of complaint—permitted by Rules of Civil Procedure

Summary

In a case arising from a motor vehicle accident, the Rules of Civil Procedure did not preclude the relation back of defendant's counterclaim to the date that the complaint was filed, and therefore defendant's counterclaim–which was filed one day after both the filing of plaintiff's complaint and the expiration of the three-year statute of limitations in N.C.G.S. § 1-52(16)–was not time-barred. Since, pursuant to Rule 3, the filing of a compulsory counterclaim does not amount to the commencement of a civil action, counterclaims relate back to the date an action is filed, and the Supreme Court overruled a prior Court of Appeals decision that concluded otherwise.

Summary from the North Carolina Reports digest (official subject index). Read the opinion →

The record

DecisionReversed and Remanded
Docket176PA22
CountyNew Hanover County